Best Discussion Books: The Great Apes' Picks

Today Jeff Potter, a member of The Great Apes Reading Group of Fort Collins, Colorado, shares the three books that sparked their best discussions. The group's name comes from their 10th reading selection, Tarzan of the Apes. The main character in the book is "an avid reader, even teaching himself to read by reading Paradise Lost, if you can believe that," says Jeff. The Great Apes, an all-guy book club with members ranging in age from 37 to 64, has been going strong for 15 years.


Undaunted Courage: Meriwether Lewis, Thomas Jefferson, and the Opening of the American West may be the best non-fiction book most of us have ever read; I personally would call it such. We still refer to parts of it even twelve years later, especially the sad ending after the trip to the Pacific was completed. Stephen Ambrose has the ability to put us right on the trail with Lewis and Clark and we see the country, or what became part of the country, unfold right before our eyes. We couldn't believe that only one Corps of Discovery soldier died over the course of the two year trip. Ambrose captures the personal and personality struggles of each soldier, too. Leadership is a big theme and I'm not sure anyone today could complete the task Jefferson charged Lewis and Clark with without lots of infighting and egos getting in the way. The psychology behind the choosing of the Corps is fascinating. If history was always taught in such a readable fashion, it would be much more popular!

Endurance: Shackleton's Incredible Voyage by Alfred Lansing is similar to Ambrose's book: adventure, leadership, personalities, psychology, devotion to a crew and a cause. The world was a different place when Shackleton ran his ad soliciting men for a mission to the South Pole that you "probably wouldn't return from," but the men that signed up were very recognizable to us all. We contrasted Shackleton's leadership style and motives with that of the Everest guides in Krakauer's Into Thin Air. Very well researched and readable about an expedition that many people have forgotten about or never even knew about. We can all learn something about committment to a cause and to a crew as Shackleton goes for help...and returns with help months and months later. It's an unforgettable expedition and an unforgettable read, simply an unbelievable story.

The Master and Margarita is an incredibly inventive novel that crosses all genre boundaries. It's historical, religious/spiritual, satiric, full of magic realism (see the "cat"!), political and more all at once. We talked about this over two meetings and on occasion still return to plumb its depths and keep trying to wrap our minds around what Bulgakov has created. A background in basic Russian political history and early Christianity is helpful, but probably not necesary as long as one reads with an open mind. It's also a psychological and philosophical study too, so there is no limit to the discussion subjects. I don't think any of us had ever read any Bulgakov before we happened on this novel, but we are all glad we read it even if we can't neatly tie it all together! This was one of our first foreign novels that offered a variety of translations, so we received an education of how the translation can influence the reading or the meaning. Fascinating and rewarding but definitely not for everyone.