Are You a Happy Hater?
Over the course of my career, I have had the opportunity to interview all kinds of authors; first for a local Atlanta area radio show, and now for the Better World Books Podcast. Several of the authors, including Sarah Addison Allen (who I interviewed yesterday) have said they are committed to writing happy endings and are willing to take whatever criticism comes their way for that.
My question is what the heck is so wrong with being happy?
Mary Kay Andrews is another author who has told me directly that she wants to write fun books that people will enjoy. She’s not looking to uncover the deepest, darkest corners of the human psyche or unmask the evil that lives in the world. In fact, just the opposite. She and Sarah Addison Allen are both actively engaged in giving people something to smile about.
And here’s the thing. Their books sell. Loads of people like to feel good. Imagine that. But somehow we’ve marginalized these books and don’t necessarily give them their literary due. Book clubs don’t choose them and readers feel they have to defend their choices.
I for one have read many books that you might consider “lighter” that had plenty of depth. There were still relationships to discuss and plot points to consider. And the fact that I was able to read the book quickly and didn’t feel like curling up in the fetal position when I got finished was a just a bonus.
So, I’m here to stand up for happy books. And books where our heroine gets her man. And books where the bad guy is caught and world is saved. I say read them proudly. And not just on the beach. Don’t be afraid to recommend them for book club either. Your group might actually appreciate a break from all the gloom and doom.
-- Dana Barrett, Contributing Editor
My question is what the heck is so wrong with being happy?
Mary Kay Andrews is another author who has told me directly that she wants to write fun books that people will enjoy. She’s not looking to uncover the deepest, darkest corners of the human psyche or unmask the evil that lives in the world. In fact, just the opposite. She and Sarah Addison Allen are both actively engaged in giving people something to smile about.
And here’s the thing. Their books sell. Loads of people like to feel good. Imagine that. But somehow we’ve marginalized these books and don’t necessarily give them their literary due. Book clubs don’t choose them and readers feel they have to defend their choices.
I for one have read many books that you might consider “lighter” that had plenty of depth. There were still relationships to discuss and plot points to consider. And the fact that I was able to read the book quickly and didn’t feel like curling up in the fetal position when I got finished was a just a bonus.
So, I’m here to stand up for happy books. And books where our heroine gets her man. And books where the bad guy is caught and world is saved. I say read them proudly. And not just on the beach. Don’t be afraid to recommend them for book club either. Your group might actually appreciate a break from all the gloom and doom.
-- Dana Barrett, Contributing Editor
2 Comments:
hi, Our book group usually avoids the "happy" books because they aren't "literary" enough, but we recently read a Debbie Macomber book.
Surprisingly even even the folks who orignally scoffed at the selection, liked the book and found some interesting and challenging items to discuss. We came to the conclusion that while we liked a little more depth, we were in a book group to read books outside our normal "comfort" zone. We have decided to read more books that are outside the more formal literary works. It was nice to be happy!
I'm new to this forum but I'll have to admit that while I completely revere Oprah and her books, I don't usually read the ones on her list, because all too often I'm emotionally empty or spent by the time I'm done. I consider myself an eclectic reader and while, I don't read just chic-lit or fiction, I love biographies, I love the lighter reads for that upbeat ending. Kudos to you to point out that just because it isn't Anna Karinana and the main character isn't throwing herself under a train, then it isn't literary worthy! =) The real world is already too emotionally draining sometimes our brains need a break!
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home